A Load of Rubbish

June 6th, 2007

I’m pretty open minded when it comes to other cultures, and different values, but there is one thing which I just don’t get in Indonesia: what they do with their rubbish.

People seem to have a totally different attitudes toward a clean environment. Although the will keep the insides of their houses spotless, there is so much rubbish littered all over the place. Piles of rubbish collect in open spaces and the open sewer, people are quite happy to throw rubbish on the ground, or out of vehicles. It’s been said that in developing countries people are used to all the rubbish biodegrading, and the problem is with all the plastics and other such materials which have been introduced from the West. When I order food here, it is wrapped up in a banana leaf and paper, then put in a plastic bag (the sort they use for everything), which always makes me cringe.

I think there is definitely a need for some social reconditioning here. We have had the “Be a Tidy Kiwi” campaign in New Zealand for ages, and I can remember the risk of being put on “clean up” duty if caught littering at school. None of that seems to be important here. In a city affected by conflict, devastated by a tsunami and with already high poverty rates, it might not be such a high priority. However it seem like not littering is a small thing which all people can contribute to - and benefit from.

Even when the rubbish is collected here, it seems the primary means of disposal is to burn it. At night there will be lots of little fires around the neighborhood, as people dispose of all of their household rubbish and garden waste. The plumes of black smoke rising into the air also make me cringe!
I do wonder if burning the rubbish could be used to generate electricity, but for such small amounts, it’s probably not worth it - and I’d hate to encourage people to keep burning their rubbish.

However, since moving into my own house (more on that later), I’ve been responsible for disposing of my own rubbish, and have resigned myself to the fact of burning it as well. So last weekend, I collected all of my rubbish, and made my own little fire in the backyard, which freaked out the monkey (did I mention that I had a monkey in my backyard?). I also took the opportunity to clean up all of the rubbish which was also scattered throughout my backyard. To my credit I would like to mention that I separate all biodegradables, and have made a compost heap - which seems to be a completely foreign concept here. With the tropical climate, I hope this will produce fertile soil from growing some more plants here.

The day after my clean up, I went outside and was shocked to find even more rubbish scattered throughout my back yard!!! Had the neighbors just thrown their rubbish over the fence? I was furious. On closer inspection I released that the rubbish was actually mine, and then it dawned on me! I had hired a cleaner to clean my house that day, and to get rid of my rubbish she had simply opened the backdoor and thrown it outside! And then scattered it round, so it didn’t look so bad (but was much harder to collect).

I considered hiring her again, specifically to tidy my backyard, but I couldn’t bring myself to do it. It seemed too condescending, like rubbing a pet’s nose in the mess they made. I resigned myself to the fact that this isn’t my week for changing the world, but after going back and collecting all of the rubbish, at least my back yard is tidy.

[?] Share This

11 Responses to “A Load of Rubbish”

  1. Roni Says:

    That’s something that I’ve had to try to come to terms with in my travels also and it never settles well no matter how long you’re around it. I found out while in Mexico and Guatemala (and I’m sure it stands for a lot of the other countries I was in too) that to have a lot of rubbish implies to other people that you’re wealthy because you can afford to buy things that come with wrappers and packaging…can you imagine anyone at home thinking you were wealthy for piling up rubbish outside your home???

  2. D Says:

    It could be when you have little or nothing the only thing you can concentrate on is your own living and survial. Anything goes until you reach a state where thought can be given to the environment. See Tragedy of the Commons

  3. Tom L Says:

    “which freaked out the monkey” …

    Now is the time to train the monkey to start collecting the garbage.

  4. Michael Says:

    Roni,
    I hadn’t thought that people would use rubbish as a sign of wealth, and if that’s the case - you are we to object? We value a clean environment, and they value piles of rubbish? who am I to say that my way is right..

    Dad,
    I would argue for a more holistic view, as looking after the environment is a part of your own living and survival. If it is always an afterthought, then it will never be given the priority it needs.
    And here’s a link on the Tragedy of the Commons.

    Tom,
    I have stories and photos of the monkey, which I wouldn’t dare put on my blog. Let’s just say that it’s a little deranged… I probably would be too if I was left chained to a tree (it’s my neighbor’s “pet”)
    And anyway, wouldn’t it be wrong to expect animals to clean up our rubbish?

  5. Gareth Says:

    So how come your neighbours monkey is in your back yard?

  6. Michael Says:

    Gareth,
    It’s a sort of common backyard, our houses are pretty close. And the idea of private property doesn’t apply quite as strong here.

  7. Leiselb Says:

    I’m falling off my chair….the monkey…the word “rubbish” (so much nicer than “trash”)…the compost…the cleaning lady tossing it in the backyard…I’m not even sure what to laugh at first!It’s a pity you’ve made me so confused…;)

  8. Michael Says:

    Glad to be entertaining. The latest episode in the on going saga was me finding that the neighbors were putting all of their rubbish in the compost heap!!! And burning it there!!! This required me to first remove the rubbish, then talk to all my neighbors, to explain that it was for compost only. I think that they understood…

  9. Leiselb Says:

    Now…do they get what “compost” means though? I’d love to know how that translation went over…;-)

    And I find myself a complete geek– I’ve refreshed your page about fifteen times to watch the banner change pictures. Very fun but clearly I need to get a life….

  10. Michael Says:

    Compost translates to “puput” which people actually seem to understand. Why it is still a foreign concept… I don’t know.

  11. MEG Says:

    Perhaps your other mission is to bring the concept of compost to Banda Aceh!
    Where’s this changing banner?

Leave a Reply


Close
E-mail It